Why Few CNAs Become Nurses and How Alabama Is Trying to Fix It

By
Craft Education Staff
November 19, 2026
Share this post

Few certified nursing assistants go straight on to nurse training. In a 2018 federal evaluation of a job-training program, only 3 percent of CNA training completers went on to train as a licensed practical nurse (LPN) or registered nurse (RN) during the program.

In 2021, Alabama passed a law to help change that. It lets the state's Board of Nursing approve student nurse apprenticeships, so nursing students can work and be paid in a hospital while they finish school. By fall 2025, 87 employers and 28 colleges and universities in the state had taken part.

This post builds on reporting by Colleen Connolly for The Hechinger Report, produced in partnership with Work Shift and published in December 2025. We checked its numbers against federal, state, and college sources and updated them where newer figures exist.

The nursing ladder

Three jobs sit on the main rungs of the nursing ladder. Each has different schooling and a different paycheck.

A certified nursing assistant, or CNA, provides basic care and helps patients with daily activities such as bathing, dressing, moving between a bed and a wheelchair, and eating. Nursing assistants often complete a state-approved education program and pass a state competency exam. Those who pass are placed on a state registry, which is required to work in a nursing home. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reports a median pay of $42,260 a year for nursing assistants (May 2025). "Median" means half of workers earn more and half earn less.

A licensed practical nurse, or LPN, provides basic medical care, such as checking blood pressure, body temperature, and other vital signs, and changing bandages. LPNs typically work under the supervision of registered nurses and doctors. LPN programs typically take about one year, followed by a licensing exam. The BLS median pay is $64,400 a year.

A registered nurse, or RN, delivers and coordinates patient care. That includes assessing patients' conditions, planning their care, administering medicines and treatments, and teaching patients and families how to manage an illness. RNs graduate from an approved nursing program and pass a licensing exam. A bachelor's degree is the typical entry-level requirement, though associate degree and diploma graduates can also qualify for entry-level staff nurse jobs. The BLS median pay is $97,550 a year, more than double the CNA figure.

Each step up the ladder brings a bigger raise, and it also means more school. That gap is what this post is about.

Why the ladder stalls at the first rung

The 3 percent figure comes from the Health Professions Opportunity Grants program (HPOG), a federal effort funded starting in 2010 to train low-income adults for health care jobs. A 2018 report by the Urban Institute for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services looked at 9,642 people who completed CNA training in the program between September 2010 and March 2016. "Only 3 percent of CNA training completers went on to train as either an LPN or an RN," the report found, and only 1 percent earned an associate degree or higher while in the program.

Those figures capture only training recorded during the program, and the report notes that some participants may have pursued advanced training afterward, so they may understate how many went on later. The Hechinger Report also cites a California study in which 22 percent of people who completed community college CNA certificates later earned a higher-level health care credential, but only 13 percent became registered nurses within six years.

The CNA training itself was short. Participants finished it in 1.9 months on average. Pay was modest, too. The report put the national average CNA wage at $13.29 an hour in 2016, and HPOG participants working as CNAs averaged $11.97 an hour 15 months after enrolling. The federal summary of the report describes the challenge this way: "beyond these trainings achieving the next step on the career ladder can be challenging."

The structure of nursing school adds to the problem. Clinical hours, the supervised time spent caring for real patients that every nursing program requires, are usually unpaid. For a working CNA, moving up can mean giving up paid hours to complete unpaid ones.

The same summary recommended partnering with employers to create CNA apprenticeships or extended programs that let CNAs build skills and earn more while working, along with financial, academic, and other supports for people completing longer nursing programs.

The stakes are real. According to the Health Resources and Services Administration's December 2025 projections, demand for RNs will exceed supply by 8 percent in 2028 and 3 percent in 2038. For LPNs, the gap is projected to grow from 17 percent in 2028 to 30 percent in 2038.

What an apprenticeship actually is

The U.S. Department of Labor describes an apprenticeship as a career pathway that combines four things: paid work experience, classroom instruction, mentorship, and a nationally recognized credential. The length varies by employer and occupation.

In nursing, that means you hold a paid job with an employer such as a hospital, take your nursing classes at a partner college, and do your supervised patient care as paid work instead of unpaid practice. Here are the terms you are most likely to run into:

  • Apprentice. The person learning. In Alabama's nursing programs, apprentices are paid for their clinical work, unlike most clinical hours, which are unpaid.
  • Journeyworker. An experienced mentor who guides the apprentice's on-the-job learning and assesses progress. In nursing, that is a licensed nurse. Infirmary Health, a hospital system in Alabama, describes the experience as one-on-one, in-hospital training with an LPN or RN.
  • Clinical hours. Time spent caring for real patients under supervision, which every nursing program requires.
  • Last-dollar scholarship. The employer covers the tuition and eligible school expenses left over after other aid has been applied. The Alabama Department of Labor describes it this way in a partnership between Baptist Health System and Tuskegee University.
  • Wage steps. Pay rises as the apprentice learns new skills. According to EdNC, employers in Alabama's apprenticeship programs provide wage increases as apprentices master new skills.

Two things stay the same, and they matter if you worry about cutting corners. First, the apprenticeship happens inside a nursing program the Alabama Board of Nursing has already approved. Under the Board's rule, that program awards the clinical credit hours, and the apprentice's training has to match the clinical course those hours count toward. Second, you still have to graduate and pass the licensing exam to become an LPN or RN, just as every nurse does.

The trade-off is a commitment. At Mobile Infirmary, according to a profile from the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, students must stay at the hospital for one year after completing the apprenticeship, and many stay longer. That is one hospital's program, not a rule for every employer.

If you are weighing this for your own organization, the questions that come next are practical ones. Who registers the program with the federal government? Who delivers the classroom instruction? How do you track every hour and every mentor sign-off? And how do you pay for it? Those are the questions we work on at Craft. We handle federal apprenticeship registration, line up a national academic partner for the classroom instruction, and give you one place where apprentices log hours and mentors approve them. Your nurses stay the mentors, and your organization stays the employer, because we do not provide mentors or employ apprentices.

What Alabama did

The barrier Alabama went after was simple: nursing students typically do their clinical hours unpaid. In April 2021, the state legislature passed Act 2021-275 (Senate Bill 179), which authorizes the Alabama Board of Nursing to set standards for student nurse apprenticeships and to issue apprentice permits.

The Board began issuing and regulating student nurse apprentice permits on March 17, 2022. You may see this called a nursing apprenticeship license in some coverage, but the Board's own term is a permit. Either way, it allows a student to perform approved nursing skills, in approved facilities, under the supervision of licensed nurses.

The Board's rule for these programs adds guardrails. Only a nursing program the Board has already approved can start an apprenticeship and award clinical credit for it, and the college keeps oversight of the apprentice's clinical work. Before an apprentice does a task, the program has to validate that the apprentice is competent to do it.

Many groups helped build it. According to the Alabama Department of Labor, the student nurse apprenticeship was created through the efforts of the Alabama Office of Apprenticeship, the Alabama Community College System, the Alabama Board of Nursing, and employers. A nursing apprenticeship playbook posted on the Board's website adds that the Board worked with the legislature on the changes and made sure the new permit fit existing education and licensure requirements.

The state also offers employers a financial nudge. According to EdNC, employers that create new apprenticeship programs or add new occupations can have the state reimburse 50 percent of wages for 480 hours of work, up to $5,400 per apprentice, for their first 10 apprentices. That incentive reaches many occupations, not only nursing.

Alabama's incentive is a state program, and funding looks different for every organization. At Craft, we map the funding options by site and region, prepare the applications, and braid streams such as WIOA, Perkins, and Workforce Pell. When the funding stack lines up, the cost to the employer is low. We cannot guarantee funding, but we can show you what may be available for your organization.

What has happened since

The programs have multiplied

Coastal Alabama Community College started its first practical nursing apprentices with Infirmary Health in summer 2022. By fall 2025, EdNC reports, the statewide program had grown to 1,000 apprentices, 87 employers, and 28 colleges and universities. A profile from the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, with figures as of December 2025, counted 80 employers, 28 colleges and universities, and about 450 people who had completed the program. The counts differ because they were taken at different times. In March 2026, the Alabama Department of Labor announced that Tuskegee University had joined 30 other postsecondary institutions offering the program.

Early results are encouraging

In August 2023, Coastal Alabama Community College reported that 100 percent of the enrollees in its first-year practical nursing apprenticeship passed their board exams. The announcement did not say how many students were in that group.

The American Academy profile reports that Mobile Infirmary has hosted 90 apprentices since 2022, and 85 are still employed there. It also says staff retention is higher among students who complete a hospital's apprenticeship than among those who do not, though the profile does not publish data for that claim. Students say they learn more from one-on-one training than from group clinical hours.

What the evidence does not show yet

These are early signs, not proof. Most of the results come from the programs themselves, and the Board's playbook describes research comparing apprenticeships with traditional clinical training as still preliminary.

There are practical limits, too. The American Academy profile lists a shortage of mentors as an obstacle, since each apprentice needs one. It also points to strict licensing requirements that call for careful program design, and to the work of defining what student apprentices may do. And unlike other nursing apprenticeships, which serve nurses who are already licensed, Alabama's is designed for students.

That licensing piece is why we treat nursing carefully at Craft. Nursing pathways are emerging where a state's scope-of-practice rules and academic partners allow, and most of the healthcare programs we see start one rung down, with CNA, patient care technician, or medical assistant apprenticeships that feed a nursing pipeline. We can design a CNA pathway on request.

What to take from Alabama's experience

  • The first rung is hard to climb. In the federal HPOG program, only 3 percent of CNA training completers went on to train as an LPN or RN during the program, and nursing school's clinical hours are usually unpaid.
  • Alabama's 2021 law lets students be paid for supervised clinical work. By fall 2025, the program had 1,000 apprentices, 87 employers, and 28 colleges and universities.
  • Early results are encouraging but limited. They come mostly from the programs themselves, and a shortage of mentors is a real constraint.

Thinking about building the first rung of your own? Schedule a call with Craft. In a 30-minute discovery call, we will talk through which pathway fits your organization, what funding may be available, and what registration involves.

‍

Share this post

Sign up for our newsletter

Stay up to date with the latest news, insights, and resources from Craft.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy & Terms of Service and provide consent to receive updates from Craft.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Site Search

Craft your search below.