Why Every New Teacher Needs a Mentor

By
Teryn Bryant
November 9, 2026
Share this post

The Importance of Teacher Mentors

When I first taught middle school, the principal gave me a cart and whiteboard with wheels and pointed in the direction of an abandoned church sanctuary the school was renting that would serve as my classroom. The school leadership did not mention this during my orientation, and I was unprepared for the impact the lack of a proper classroom or materials could have on my students’ performance. I also did not have a mentor, so I spent those first weeks learning through trial and error, struggling to establish classroom routines, manage student behavior, and deliver meaningful instruction. My students deserved a teacher who could confidently lead their learning from day one, but without the support I needed, much of our early time together was spent simply trying to find our footing.

On my first day teaching first grade, I remember my excitement turning to nervous apprehension when I walked into an empty classroom of thirty tiny desks and chairs that would soon be filled with students whom I would have to nurture and guide and grow through a critical stage of early development. When I asked another teacher for ideas of how to make this classroom feel more fun and welcoming, they responded, “Just put some paper on the wall”—which only heightened my anxiety. But then my district-assigned mentor arrived at my door with a box of picture books and a reassuring smile. She was not bothered by the deer-in-headlights look on my face. I felt so lost and overwhelmed that I asked her, “What do I do when the students come in?” Her response was simple: “Talk to them.” It wasn't rocket science, but it was much needed guidance at that moment.

Every year, thousands of new teachers start the school year with the same excitement and uncertainty. The responsibilities and challenges in the first year of teaching can seem insurmountable and isolating. Starting on the very first day of school, new teachers are expected to perform the same duties and tasks as their veteran colleagues—from designing lessons that engage students to grading dozens of assignments per day to monitoring students’ academic progress to the unspoken expectations of long work hours and extra duties.

That moment captures something essential about mentorship: having someone to turn to while learning to teach. That support can begin during student teacher training and continue into the first years of full-time teaching. During student teaching, mentors—referred to as cooperating teachers—model classroom teaching and classroom management; help student teachers develop and teach lessons; support their growth through reflection and revision; and acquaint them with the tools of the trade like class curricula, exercises and activities, and technology. Research shows that the role of a cooperating teacher can make a meaningful difference: good cooperating teachers improve student teachers’ skills and help them feel better prepared when they enter the classroom. One study found that first-year teachers who had especially high-quality mentorship during their student teaching are as effective as second- or even third-year teachers. 

Making that support available means adapting mentorship to different teacher preparation pathways. In traditional teacher prep, students study teaching as they earn their bachelor’s degree, and often student teach for a full semester. This affords them an extended period to learn from cooperating teachers as they try their hand at leading a classroom. But as fewer undergraduates opt to study education, other pathways into the profession have created ways for career changers, school district employees, and other nontraditional learners to become teachers. These pathways are important for giving people the opportunity to enter the teaching profession, but they have very different timelines and structures that can make incorporating mentorship complicated. We wrote a separate post describing these pathways if you’re interested in learning more.

The need for support continues once teachers complete their training and move into the classroom. Mentors are the cornerstones of induction programs that provide support for new teachers and orient them to the demands of the teaching profession. They offer guidance, feedback, and professional development as new teachers learn and develop their craft. New teachers face a steep set of demands—they assume full responsibility for the learning and wellbeing of their students, just as veteran teachers do, juggling lesson planning, managing students’ peer interactions, grading assignments, talking with parents, and a host of other duties. Mentors guide them in managing these responsibilities and play a critical role in new teachers’ sense of belonging and in helping to cultivate their professional success. 

With all the responsibilities new teachers shoulder, the early years of teaching are notoriously difficult: new teachers have long reported feelings of isolation, and overwork and burnout are pervasive across the profession. And new teachers are expected to keep up with the same workload that even their more experienced colleagues find unmanageable. With these pressures, a turnover rate of nearly 20% for teachers with one to three years of experience seems unsurprising. A survey of teachers with 5 years of experience or less found that 70% had considered leaving or had already left the profession—and when these teachers were asked why they’d thought about leaving, nearly 75% cited a lack of support. This broad set of adversities makes institutional support like mentorship especially crucial as teachers begin their careers. And research bears this out: most studies find that new teachers with good mentorship stay longer and their students perform better on state tests.

Joy Bramlette, a former school leader who spent decades supporting new teachers, and one of my mentors, summarized it like this: “Mentoring new teachers is critical. Teaching is overwhelmingly hard. You are placed in a room with 20-50 youngsters, depending on the grade level, and told to teach them the essential skills and strategies for learning in general and various content specific practice. To have a mentor, a veteran who has walked in those shoes daily, is essential. New teachers need an experienced mentor to celebrate small successes with, scream or cry when everything falls apart or goes horribly wrong, to laugh when kids say or write the darndest things.”

Structuring Mentorship Models

The research and these personal experiences point to the value of mentorship. Yet teacher preparation and induction programs do not always deliberately build in that support. It can be more convenient for programs and districts to select available, rather than effective, teachers. Often mentor and cooperating teachers take on supporting new teachers on top of their plethora of ongoing responsibilities, without being relieved of any existing duties. And they’re frequently under- or unpaid for their mentoring work. It’s not uncommon for student and new teachers not to have assigned mentors at all. In a survey of early-career teachers, about one in six reported not having an assigned mentor. Throughout my career as an administrator, I’ve witnessed classrooms on the same hallway in the same grade level have drastically different new teacher orientation professional development based on the caliber of the mentor they had. And it’s painful to watch—especially knowing who the ultimate recipient of the classroom teacher is: the students.

Research offers guidance on what can work. First, mentorship in student teaching and for new teachers needs to be deliberately structured by programs and districts. This can start with selecting highly qualified teachers to be mentors, and pairing them with student or new teachers with the same subject area and grade level focus. Multiple studies have shown that when programs and districts specifically select effective teachers to mentor student and new teachers, the mentees become better teachers. It also matters that mentors have taught in environments similar to those where their mentees will teach. 

Selecting mentors is only the beginning. The frequency and quality of mentor-mentee interactions support new teacher candidates during their formative years in the profession, helping them grow into effective teachers. Studies of teacher mentorship have shown that mentors play a wide range of roles and have myriad functions: they model leading their own classrooms and delivering lessons, they coach new teachers on instructional practice, they help new teachers navigate school as a workplace. In the words of my own mentor, Stephanie Brown, “I think an effective mentor is someone that offers advice, collaborates, and is willing to demonstrate effective teaching. No one has all the answers, but being reflective in your own practice helps to show others that teaching adapts and changes over time.” 

Putting these elements into practice takes planning, resources, and time. Research points to several ways programs and districts can make room for them. For one, teacher prep programs can work deliberately to identify effective teachers within a reasonable distance to place their student teachers with. To broaden the pool of teachers willing to serve as mentors, districts might consider increasing mentor stipends. Because a good mentor can make a first-year teacher as effective as a second-year teacher, there’s an argument for tying mentorship stipends to the difference between first- and second-year teacher pay, which the researchers estimate falls between $1,100 and $1,800 nationally. 

There isn’t a lot of reliable data on how much cooperating teachers earn for their work (for more on the holes in teacher workforce data, see one of our other posts!). In many places, it’s a small amount, though not everywhere. We were able to find a few examples of cooperating teacher stipends to give an idea: $150 in Maine, $400 in New York, and $2,500 in Pennsylvania.

Compensation is one part of the equation; time is another. Relieving mentors of other responsibilities can give them more time to work with mentees and might encourage more teachers to take on the role. Teachers are stretched very thin, and good mentorship is time-intensive. To get the most out of mentorship, it’s important that it’s afforded the time it deserves. So having mentors teach one fewer class, or letting them off of lunch duty or pickup supervising, might help increase their impact.

Alongside compensation and time, successful mentors also need preparation and ongoing support. Mentors are more effective when they’re trained, and mentees are more successful when mentorship is part of a broader set of induction supports like peer collaboration, administrative support, and coaching. As of 2025, 32 states had formal induction programs that included key components like training for both mentors and new teachers. However, having programs in place is only a starting point: their implementation and quality can vary widely. While states and districts can outline a structure for mentoring, that structure must come with supports for enacting all the complementary elements of effective mentorship. 

Making Meaningful Mentorship Models

A few states have taken on the challenge of establishing meaningful mentorship models for student and new teachers. We highlight initiatives in Louisiana, Texas, New Mexico, and Pennsylvania aimed at cultivating and fostering meaningful teacher mentorship.

Louisiana and Texas

Louisiana launched a state-wide program to train teacher mentors in 2017 as part of a comprehensive effort to strengthen teacher training across the state. Louisiana teachers looking to become mentors complete a training program and assessment and, as mentors, have access to plans and materials to help them guide student teachers developing their classroom management and instructional skills. The program includes a $2,000 stipend for mentors.

Texas also has a statewide mentor training model with standardized milestones and competencies for aspiring mentor teachers to master. The Texas Mentorship Training centers on leadership and the foundations of teacher training, with a particular focus on instructional support and building school based relationships. There are two pathways to become a mentor, one for mentors and another for district leaders, but prospective mentors must have at least two years of teaching experience and demonstrated instructional and leadership skills. 

In a report on the Louisiana and Texas mentorship models by the National Institute for Excellence in Teaching (NIET), teachers noted that the states’ mentoring frameworks have been helpful. As one mentor put it, “I feel like now I have done a better job mentoring because I have guidance and criteria. I have set myself goals for where I want to be with my mentees at different points in the year and how to move on to the next phase. It gives us something to reach for” (p. 9). However, mentors also reported challenges in finding enough time in their schedules to observe, coach, and meet with their mentees. NIET highlights districts that give mentors extra planning time to accommodate their mentoring responsibilities, and recommends asynchronous observations as a potential strategy when observing mentees in person presents too many scheduling challenges.

Louisiana mentors complete a training program and assessment and receive a $2,000 stipend, while Texas requires mentors to have at least two years of teaching experience and demonstrated instructional and leadership skills.

New Mexico

New Mexico’s legislature passed a statute in 2018 that places a high premium on mentor quality. According to the legislation, mentor teachers must have recent highly effective or exemplary ratings or have national board certifications (in cases where there are no teachers with these qualifications available, the state assigns one). New teachers receive mentorship for a full year.

New Mexico (2018): mentors must have recent highly effective or exemplary ratings or national board certification, and new teachers receive mentorship for a full year.

Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania recently bolstered its teacher induction requirements. Starting in the 2024-25 school year, the state implemented a mandatory two-year induction program for new teachers. The induction program includes a requirement to assign every new teacher a mentor for the full two years, and recommends that mentors are selected according to overlap with the age range and subject area their mentees will teach, have outstanding teaching records, and have training as a mentor. The program guidelines outline what specifically mentors can focus on, like helping mentees with skills like classroom management, teaching strategies, and how to teach diverse learners like students with special needs or English learners.

Separate from its induction plan for new teachers, Pennsylvania has also rolled out a student teacher stipend program that awards up to $10,000 for student teachers and includes $2,500 stipends for student teacher mentors.

Pennsylvania (2024-25): every new teacher is assigned a mentor for a mandatory two-year induction program.

Thanks to my mentor, Stephanie, I remember slowly feeling more confident in my role as a teacher. Over the next few months, my daily tasks felt more doable as I began to trust myself and the work I was doing with my students. I began to see how the routine classroom activities I learned from Stephanie helped make connections between me and my students. By the end of my first year of teaching—thanks to my mentor—I realized that my students had learned more than just the academic standards. They learned to trust me. 

Towards the end of the year, I had a student who had become emotionally withdrawn—and I panicked. There was nothing in a teacher’s manual on how to help a withdrawn six year old. I asked my mentor how I could help this student and she gave me the same advice she’d offered in the beginning of the year: to simply “listen to them.” By listening, I learned this student had lost her older sibling in a tragic car accident. She asked if it would be okay if she could take “time outs” to collect herself when she got emotional. I immediately said yes and made accommodations for her. I felt honored to support her in that way. Reflecting back, I realized I did more for that one student than maybe all of the other students in the class—and it had nothing to do with academics. Just as my mentor had with me, I helped her feel seen. 

With contributions from Nell Williams

Share this post

Sign up for our newsletter

Stay up to date with the latest news, insights, and resources from Craft.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy & Terms of Service and provide consent to receive updates from Craft.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Site Search

Craft your search below.